Tuesday, October 27, 2009

Trivia Tuesday: More Postseason Walk-Off Trivia

This year the Yankees have celebrated with walk-offs in the postseason and walk-offs in the regular season. One of those "walk-offs" in the regular season was when Luis Castillo dropped the ball to end the game.

In 1914, an error by the pitcher on a bunt attempt gave the Boston Braves the win in the game (and the series) against the Philadelphia Athletics. Since then, only four times have postseason games ended in errors. Can you name them? Put you answers in the comments below and I'll reveal the correct answer later tonight.

*hint* only two franchises since the Boston Braves have benefited from this (so each franchise had two walk-off wins via the error)

The Answers:


Car#  G# Date          Series G Pitcher           Tm   Opp Batter            Score       Inn RoB Out Cnt Pit  R Play Desc.
+-----+---+-------------+------+-+-----------------+---+----+-----------------+-----------+---+---+---+---+---+--+-------------------------+
   1   1 1914-10-12    WS     3 Joe Bush          PHA @BSN Herbie Moran      tied   4-4  b12 12-   0  -       1 *ENDED GAME*:Reached on E1 (throw to 3B)/Sacrifice Bunt; Mann Scores/unER/No RBI; Gilbert to 2B; Moran to 1B 
   2   1 1969-10-15    WS     4 Pete Richert      BAL @NYM J.C. Martin       tied   1-1  b10 12-   0  -       1 *ENDED GAME*:Reached on E1 (throw to 1B)/Sacrifice Bunt; Gaspar Scores/unER/No RBI; Weis to 2B; Martin to 1B 
   3   1 1986-10-25    WS     6 Bob Stanley       BOS @NYM Mookie Wilson     tied   5-5  b10 -2-   2 3-2   9  1 *ENDED GAME*:Reached on E3 (Ground Ball); Knight Scores/unER 
   4   1 1996-10-02    ALDS   2 Mike Henneman     TEX @NYY Charlie Hayes     tied   4-4  b12 12-   0 0-0   1  1 *ENDED GAME*:Reached on E5 (throw to 1B)/Sacrifice Bunt (Bunt to Weak 3B); Jeter Scores/No RBI/unER; Raines to 2B 
   5   1 2009-10-17    ALCS   2 Ervin Santana     LAA @NYY Melky Cabrera     tied   3-3  b13 12-   1 0-0   1  1 *ENDED GAME*:Reached on E4 (throw)/attempted forceout (Ground Ball); Hairston Scores/unER/No RBI; Cano to 2B 

7 comments:

Paul Tropeano said...

can't forget Billy Buckner

Jay Hyne said...

I'm not sure Buckner was even charged with an error on that play - he never touched the ball, and the official scorer certainly had reason to believe Mookie Wilson would have beat Buckner to the bag even if he had fielded it cleanly.

I think Merkle's boner was before 1914 (more of a blunder than an error anyway) and I don't think Matt Holliday's misplay directly ended the game a couple weeks ago.

So, I'm gonna have to go with....I have no idea. Tough question.

Andrew Katz said...

Buckner was definitely charged with an error. That, so far, is the only correct one.

Ben Wolinsky said...

1996, Game 2 ALDS, Rangers at Yankees, Yankees win
2009, Game 2 ALCS, Angels at Yankees, Yankees win

Andrew Katz said...

Ben got two more...anyone have the fourth (per the hint, it's a Mets win)

Andrew Katz said...

Nice work by everyone. Just missed one during the '69 Miracle Mets World Series

Andrew Katz said...

(Posted the answers above)

Post a Comment